The Win Rate Trap: Why 85% Win Rate Is a Red Flag
An 85% win rate sounds like a dream. Eight out of ten trades close in profit. Your account grows steadily. Every day feels like a good day.
Until the day it doesn't.
High win rates are the most commonly misunderstood metric in algorithmic trading.
How High Win Rates Are Manufactured
The most common technique is simple: never close a losing trade.
A bot opens a position. The market moves against it. Instead of taking a small loss, the bot holds the position open — for hours, days, sometimes weeks.
On the dashboard, this looks incredible: 85% win rate, steady profit curve. The unrealized loss sitting in open positions doesn't appear in the win rate calculation.
Then the market moves sharply. The account loses 40% in a single day.
The Sustainable Range
Most genuinely profitable trading strategies operate with win rates between 45% and 70%.
- Below 45%: can work with trend-following strategies where rare winners are very large
- Between 55% and 65%: the sweet spot
- Above 75%: demands intense scrutiny
- Above 85%: treat as guilty until proven innocent
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a high win rate always bad?
No. Some strategies genuinely achieve 70-80% win rates sustainably. The key is to verify that losing trades are being closed promptly.
What win rate should I look for?
Focus on the 55-70% range for most strategies. More importantly, check the profit factor and maximum drawdown.
Related Resources